If you thought cooking at home always saved money, think again. With grocery prices rising faster than restaurant menus, some “budget” meals now cost more than ordering out. Understandably, this twist can throw off your household budget—and your mindset about cooking. By knowing which meals are now pricier than takeout, you can make smarter food choices and plan accordingly. Here are 10 surprising budget dishes that may be eating into your wallet—more than your go-to restaurant might.
1. Pasta with Jarred Sauce and Parmesan
Image Source: 123rf.com
A classic pantry staple, right? But when pasta, jarred sauce, olive oil, and grated Parmesan are bought at premium prices, that dinner can top restaurant spaghetti. Jarred sauces now often include extras like garlic, herbs, and cheese that jack up costs, especially with inflation. Add quality pasta and you’re looking at $8–$10 per serving at home. In contrast, many casual eateries offer similar plates for $9–$12, tip included. Check sales or buy store brands to bring that cost back down.
2. Sheet-Pan Salmon with Veggies
Salmon is healthy—but pricey. A single sheet-pan dinner with salmon fillet and organic vegetables can cost over $15 per person. Compare that to a mid-tier seafood restaurant entrée, which might offer a sales special or market price under $18. With fish prices jumping due to supply chain issues, salmon no longer qualifies as a weekly bargain. To save, rotate in more affordable proteins like beans or chicken. Treat salmon as a special occasion dish—not a weekly fix.
3. Avocado Toast with Extras
This trendy brunch favorite can empty your wallet at home when ingredients aren’t in season. When avocados hit $1.50–$2 each, plus artisanal bread, olive oil, and toppings, the cost adds up quickly. In cafes, a basic avocado toast often runs $8–$12—sometimes including extras like eggs or sari greens. If the homemade version surpasses that, consider switching to less trendy but tasty spreads like hummus or almond butter. You’ll preserve flavor without breaking the bank.
4. Smoothie Bowls with Protein Boosts
Superfood smoothie bowls sound healthy, but the cost of frozen berries, spinach, protein powder, chia seeds, and nut butter can soar. A single bowl can cost $7–$9 just in ingredient value—and that’s before blending and serving at home. Meanwhile, a smoothie or acai bowl at a juice bar may range from $6–$10 but often uses optimized bulk recipes that are more cost-effective. To save, buy frozen fruit in bulk and skip pricier add-ons—and reserve smoothie bowls for an occasional treat.
5. “Homemade” Stir-Fries with Exotic Sauces
Buying fresh Asian greens, specialty sauces, and premium meats or tofu for a stir-fry can be pricey. A well-stocked stir-fry night may cost $12–$15 per serving. In contrast, many takeout places offer similar dishes for $10–$12 with tax and tip—which suddenly looks like a steal. Sauces like oyster or hoisin often come in large jars that expire before you use them fully. Instead, lean on staples like soy sauce, garlic, and ginger—or scale down to simpler veggie-only stir-fries to trim costs.
6. Gourmet Burgers with Specialty Toppings
Crafting a gourmet burger at home sounds fun—but specialty ground beef, artisanal buns, fancy toppings like goat cheese or arugula add up fast. Per-burger cost can easily top $10–$12 before sides. Many burger joints bundle a burger, fries, and drink for $11–$13. If your homemade creation exceeds that range, simplify by using regular ground beef and standard buns—or save high-end burgers for once-in-a-while treats.
7. Quinoa Bowls with Multiple Toppings
Quinoa once had a reputation as a health food staple, but even budget bowls loaded with quinoa, roasted veggies, tahini, and seeds can surpass $8 per serving. Restaurant grain bowls often cost $9–$11, farmscale, and may include all those toppings. Packaged quinoa is more expensive per serving than rice or pasta. Swap half quinoa with brown rice or barley to cut costs without ditching nutrition. Mix smart, and explore budget grains like lentils or farro.
8. Homemade Pizza with Pre-Made Dough
Image Source: 123rf.com
That pre-made dough plus gourmet toppings like prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, and arugula can cost $15–$18 total. Compare that to chain pizza delivery—often $12–$15 for a medium with three toppings and deals. Homemade pizza is fun, but its cost-efficiency depends on using leftover ingredients or simple toppings. Opt for store-brand dough and classic toppings like pepperoni or bell peppers. You’ll still enjoy cooking at home without overspending.
9. Vegan Meat Substitutes and Mock-Meats
Beyond plant-based wave? Vegan meats deliver protein—but at a price premium. A single pack can cost $5–$7, equaling two servings. When paired with buns and sides, a vegan burger night can rival restaurant prices of $12–$14. Unless you’re making dishes in bulk frequently, these meat substitutes may not be worth the splurge. Opt for whole-food proteins like beans, lentils, or tofu for better bang-per-buck.
10. Specialty Lattes & Coffee Drinks
Yes, technically a drink and not a meal—but adding fancy coffee creations to your at-home routine counts toward your “meal” cost. A homemade latte with oat milk, extract, and espresso grinds often costs $2.50–$3 per mug. But many coffee shops now offer pressure deals—$3 for a latte or duo-shot deal. If your kitchen brew is pricier, consider buying beans on sale, investing in a cheaper machine, or brewing regular drip and reserve dairy upgrades for outings.
What This Means for Your Budget
With grocery prices outpacing inflation—even as restaurant costs rise —some surprisingly “budget” meals now cost more per serving than eating out. The solution? Go back to basics: staple ingredients, simple recipes, bulk buys, and strategic planning. Use meal prepping and rotation to build a cost-effective routine . Cooking at home still wins—when you cook smart. Focus on adaptability, so your kitchen stays a savings tool, not a surprise expense.
Have you noticed your homemade meals costing more than takeout? Share your experience and tips in the comments below!
Read More
7 Restaurant Promotions That Had to Be Pulled After Complaints
9 Restaurants Claiming “Fresh Ingredients” but Serve You Yesterday’s Leftovers
