12 Unreasonably Priced Items In Almost Every Grocery Store

Image source: shutterstock.com

You’re not imagining it: some grocery prices feel like they were set during a dare. The frustrating part is that these pricey picks often sit in the “helpful” sections of the store, where tired shoppers grab them without thinking twice. If you learn which items are quietly inflating your total, you can swap smarter without feeling like you’re sacrificing convenience. A few simple habits, like checking unit prices and buying one step less processed, can cut your bill fast. Here are 12 common offenders and the easiest ways to dodge them.

1. Pre-Cut Fruit and Veggie Trays

Pre-cut produce costs more because you’re paying for labor, packaging, and shorter shelf life. Those trays also hide waste, since you’re often buying less usable food than it looks like. If you want the convenience, buy whole produce and cut it once for the next two days of lunches and snacks. Keep a lidded container ready so you’re not relying on motivation at 6 a.m. You’ll get the same grab-and-go benefit with a much lower cost per bite.

2. Bagged Salad Mixes

Bagged salads feel like a shortcut, but they’re usually priced far above their whole-ingredient equivalents. The portions can be inconsistent, and the “best by” date moves fast once the bag is opened. If you love quick salads, buy a head of romaine or cabbage and chop it once for multiple meals. Add a bag of carrots or cucumbers for variety without paying for prepped greens every time. You’ll still get speed, just with more control over freshness and waste.

3. Salad Kits Are Unreasonably Priced Items

Salad kits often cost as much as a full meal even though you’re mostly buying lettuce, a few toppings, and a tiny dressing packet. The add-ins can look fancy, but the amounts are usually small compared to the price. Recreate the same “kit” vibe by keeping one dressing, one crunchy topping, and one protein option on hand. When you build your own, you can scale it for a family instead of paying per bag. It’s one of the easiest swaps that still feels like a treat.

4. Single-Serve Snack Packs

Individually packed chips, crackers, and cookies can cost two to three times more than the bigger bag. The packaging also makes it easy to overbuy because it feels organized and “lunchbox ready.” Buy the big bag when it’s on sale and portion it into reusable containers or sandwich bags at home. If you want variety, rotate two snack types each week instead of buying a dozen tiny boxes. Many of these unreasonably priced items disappear from your cart once you realize you’re paying for wrappers.

5. Bottled Water

Bottled water is one of the fastest ways to pay premium prices for something you can usually get for pennies at home. Cases add up quickly, and they take up space that could be used for food you actually need. If the taste is the issue, a basic filter pitcher can make a big difference without recurring case purchases. If portability is the issue, keep a reusable bottle in the car and one in the backpack. Unreasonably priced items like bottled water feel “small” until you total them for a month.

6. Name-Brand Cereal in Smaller Boxes

Cereal pricing can be sneaky because boxes vary in size while the front looks the same. The “family size” isn’t always cheaper per ounce, and the sale tag doesn’t guarantee value. Compare unit prices and keep a short list of your best-priced cereals so you recognize a real deal. Store brands often taste nearly identical, especially for basics like flakes, puffs, and oats. If you’re watching for unreasonably priced items, cereal is a top place to start.

7. Spice Jars and Seasoning Blends

Spices in small jars can cost a lot per ounce, especially for popular blends. The jars look affordable until you compare them to bagged spices, bulk bins, or international aisles. Try buying your most-used seasonings in refill bags and keep one jar as the “refill container.” If you love blends, mix your own from a simple recipe and adjust it to your family’s taste. Unreasonably priced items like spice jars are easy to avoid once you shop by ounces instead of containers.

8. Shredded Cheese

Pre-shredded cheese costs more and often includes anti-caking agents that change how it melts. A block of cheese usually gives you more servings for less money, especially when it’s on sale. Shred a block once and store it in a container so weeknight cooking stays easy. You can also freeze shredded cheese in portions for tacos, casseroles, and pizza nights. This is one convenience item that’s simple to replace without changing your routine.

9. Prepared Deli Meals

Deli meals can be lifesavers on hectic days, but they’re priced like restaurant food with grocery-store portions. They also encourage add-on spending, like sides, drinks, and desserts, because you’re already in “takeout mode.” Keep one emergency dinner plan at home, like rotisserie chicken plus rice and frozen vegetables, so you have a fallback. If you do buy deli food, compare it to what you’d pay for a full meal kit you can stretch into leftovers. Unreasonably priced items often show up here because convenience feels urgent when you’re tired.

10. Bakery Cupcakes, Cake Slices, and “Single Treats”

Individually priced bakery treats can cost more than a full box of mix, even when they don’t taste better. The displays are designed to trigger impulse buys, especially near the front of the store. If your family loves dessert, buy a larger item when it’s discounted and portion it at home. You can also keep cookie dough or muffin mix in the pantry for fast weekend baking without premium pricing. Treats feel more fun when they’re planned, not grabbed out of guilt.

11. Ready-to-Drink Coffee and Single Pods

Bottled coffee drinks and coffee pods are convenient, but they’re some of the most expensive caffeine per ounce you can buy. The cost gets even higher when you add flavored creamers and “special” add-ins at the same time. Brew at home, then make a simple batch of iced coffee you can grab all week. If you like flavored drinks, keep one syrup or spice mix and use it consistently instead of buying new bottles. Unreasonably priced items in the coffee aisle can quietly drain a budget faster than most snacks.

12. Refrigerated Juice Shots, Smoothies, and “Wellness” Drinks

Those tiny bottles often cost as much as a full bag of fruit, even though they’re gone in two sips. The labels make them feel essential, but most benefits can come from regular produce and hydration. If you like smoothies, frozen fruit plus yogurt at home is usually far cheaper per serving. If you like juice, buy a larger bottle on sale and pour smaller portions. Unreasonably priced items in this section tend to sell because they promise a quick fix, not because they’re a good value.

Your Cart Can Be Convenient Without Being Costly

The biggest savings usually come from replacing “one-step processed” foods with a slightly more basic version. When you buy whole ingredients and do one small prep step at home, you keep convenience while cutting the markup. Start with just two swaps this week so it feels manageable, not restrictive. Watch unit prices like a hawk, because the shelf tag doesn’t tell the full story.

What’s one overpriced grocery item you keep buying anyway, and what would make you finally stop?