A routine trip to Costco turned into a legal firestorm when a warehouse shopper at the Santa Rosa, California, store was injured by a collapsing liquor display. The lawsuit, now seeking over $14 million, highlights major safety concerns about product displays and site management in large retail environments. Understanding the details of the Costco lawsuit helps customers stay informed—and prompts retailers to rethink in-store safety practices. Whether you’re a loyal Costco member or a casual shopper, this case could influence how you walk Costco’s aisles. Read on for the key facts you need to know about the lawsuit’s background and potential impact.
What’s Behind The Costco Lawsuit?
Image Source: 123rf.com
The plaintiff, Sadie Novotny, was shopping with her husband on March 22 when a heavy liquor cabinet allegedly tipped over and struck her unexpectedly. According to her lawsuit, she sustained multiple, permanent, and catastrophic injuries—including a traumatic brain injury, plus damage to her shoulder, back, and arm. Her complaint accuses Costco of negligence, premises liability, and product liability, arguing the display was unstable and improperly set. She originally filed the claim in Alameda County Superior Court before it was moved to federal court at Costco’s request. Now she’s seeking $14.1 million in damages, including pain, suffering, emotional distress, and medical expenses.
Costco’s Defense Strategy
Costco has responded with a motion to dismiss one defendant—Costco Wholesale Membership, Inc.—arguing it isn’t legally connected to store operations. Their defense will likely argue that the display complied with standards or that the plaintiff’s actions contributed to the incident. They’ll also challenge the extent and legitimacy of claimed injuries. Meanwhile, Novotny’s team demands safety protocols and accountability for display maintenance. The case is now proceeding in the U.S. District Court for Northern California.
Why the Amount Is So High
Novotny’s $14.1 million claim breaks down into several categories: $9 million for physical pain and suffering, $5 million in emotional distress, plus over $2 million covering medical bills and lost wages. She’s also seeking potential future costs, like long-term care for her traumatic brain injury and permanent disabilities. The large amount reflects expected high medical costs, lost earning potential, and chronic impairment. These kinds of injury claims—especially involving brain trauma—often warrant significant damage awards. If successful, this lawsuit could show how seriously courts treat major slip-and-fall hazards in large retail settings.
What It Means for Costco and Shoppers
If Novotny wins—or Costco settles—the case, it could set a precedent that changes store-display standards not just at Costco but across the retail industry. Retailers may need to inspect shelving more frequently, stabilize heavy displays more securely, and install warnings. It might also impact Costco’s public image, leading to increased safety investments at high-traffic warehouse locations. For shoppers, the case highlights the importance of caution when browsing large fixtures like stacked pallets and floor models. Ultimately, the Costco lawsuit could raise national awareness about in-store safety for big-box retailers.
What Happens Next in Legal Terms
The lawsuit will move toward a case management conference scheduled for September in the San Francisco federal courthouse. During pre-trial discovery, attorneys will exchange video footage, inspection logs, and maintenance records. Experts—like industrial safety engineers and medical professionals—will likely testify on display stability and the extent of Novotny’s injuries. Costco may file counterclaims or additional motions aiming to limit liability or reduce damages. If the case doesn’t settle, it could go before a jury by next year.
Lessons for Smart, Safe Shopping
Whether this lawsuit ends in a multimillion-dollar payout or discrete safety measures, it’s a wake-up call. Always exercise caution in warehouse-style environments: stay alert around large displays and pay attention to unstable pallets. Retailers should proactively inspect fixtures, label hazards, and train staff on load limits. If you’re injured, document everything—medical visits, photos of the scene, and witness testimony can make a major difference. The Costco lawsuit may change official policies, but vigilance in aisles starts with each of us.
When Safety Meets Accountability, Change Happens
The Costco lawsuit’s significance stretches beyond one customer or one store. It underscores how everyday retail environments can become dangerous—and how legal action can drive systemic safety improvements. Whether you’re a frequent Costco shopper or just care about safer shopping environments, this case bears watching. As it progresses, it could reshape liability norms—and keep consumers safer in the future.
Were you surprised to learn how display hazards could lead to traumatic brain injuries in a store? Share your in-store safety experiences or thoughts about product display risks in the comments below!
Read More
Costco Just Changed Its Store Hours—Here’s What You Need to Know
